How Google’s AI Overviews Are Changing Local Search (And What Mediation & Legal Businesses Must Do Now)

Professional Mediation Insights | February 6, 2026

How Google’s AI Overviews Are Changing Local Search (And What Mediation & Legal Businesses Must Do Now)

Google is quietly reshaping local search results.

For years, “near me” searches had a predictable rhythm: a map, three listings, phone buttons, directions, and a steady stream of calls. Now Google is testing AI Overviews that can push the Local Pack down—and in some cases replace it entirely with an AI summary at the top of the page.

If you run a mediation practice, a law office, or any local professional service, this matters for one simple reason: you can lose calls without “losing rankings.”

AI is changing the layout, the click behavior, and the rules of visibility.

What Actually Changed in Local Search

Historically, when someone searched “divorce mediator near me” or “civil mediator in Dallas,” Google gave the user a map and a shortlist. That shortlist was the Local Pack. If you earned your way into it, you enjoyed prime real estate.

Google is now experimenting with a different experience: an AI Overview that summarizes the answer and may surface recommendations, context, and local business info—sometimes where the map pack used to dominate.

Even when the map pack still shows up, it may appear lower on the page, after the AI text. That scroll distance changes human behavior. People “feel answered” earlier and click less.

Why This Hits Mediators and Law Firms Hard

Local professional services run on trust and urgency.

When someone searches for mediation, they often want:

• A credible professional

• Clear pricing expectations

• The next step (call, consult, book)

• Confidence that they’re choosing the right person

When AI Overviews appear, Google can satisfy the early “confidence” part right inside search. That means fewer users reach your website. Some never even open the map listings.

And this isn’t a theory. Multiple studies and reports have shown meaningful click-through declines on queries where AI Overviews appear. Search Engine Land, referencing Seer Interactive’s analysis, reported organic CTR drops on queries with AI Overviews.

So if you’re watching your numbers and thinking, “My rankings look fine—why are calls down?” this layout shift is a strong suspect.

The New Reality: Google Doesn’t Just List Businesses—It “Explains” Them

The Local Pack used to be a list.

AI Overviews are more like a narrator.

Instead of presenting three options and letting the user decide, the AI can:

• summarize what a mediator does

• explain what to expect in a divorce mediation

• mention what to look for in a local provider

• sometimes name businesses or cite sources

That changes the game from “be top 3” to be understood and trusted by the system that writes the summary.

Google’s own guidance on succeeding in AI-powered search experiences points in a clear direction: make content unique, helpful, and satisfying for visitors—especially as people ask longer, more specific questions.

What Google’s AI Seems to Pull From (And What You Control)

No one outside Google has the full recipe. But we can work from what consistently influences local visibility and trust signals.

1) Your Google Business Profile Still Matters—But You Need to Treat It Like a “Source”

Not just a listing.

If your Google Business Profile (GBP) is thin, outdated, or inconsistent, you’re giving AI less confidence. Tighten these areas:

• Primary category + secondary categories: pick the closest match to what you actually do (mediation first, not “law firm” unless you are one)

• Services section: add structured services (family mediation, custody mediation, workplace disputes, commercial mediation)

• Business description: write clearly, with your niche and geography (no fluff)

• Photos: office, headshots, signage, credentials—signals of legitimacy

• Q&A: seed common questions (and answer them) in a professional tone

2) Consistency Across the Web Is Not “Old SEO” — It’s AI Hygiene

AI Overviews pull from multiple sources. That includes directories and review platforms.

Make sure your name, address, phone, and service area match across:

• GBP

• your website

• legal/mediation directories

• Yelp/Apple Maps/Bing Places (if applicable)

• professional associations and chamber listings

When the internet repeats the same facts about you, Google has less reason to doubt them.

3) Reviews Have Become a Visibility Asset, Not Just Reputation

You already know reviews build trust. Now add another layer: reviews also help systems understand what clients experience and what you specialize in.

Don’t chase fake volume. Build credible depth:

• ask after successful sessions (when the client is calm and satisfied)

• encourage specificity (“family mediation,” “custody agreement,” “helped us reach a settlement”)

• respond professionally (not defensively, not robotic)

If you’re a mediator, reviews also address the biggest buyer fear: “Will this person handle conflict well?”

4) Your Website Needs Pages That Answer Real Questions, Not Brochure Copy

AI Overviews thrive on question-style searches. The best local sites don’t just say “We offer mediation.” They explain the messy situations people are actually in.

Create pages that match intent:

Service pages (clear, specific):

• Divorce Mediation

• Child Custody Mediation

• Workplace/HR Mediation

• Business Dispute Mediation

• Pre-litigation Settlement Mediation

Local pages (if you serve multiple cities):

• Divorce Mediation in [City]

• Family Mediation in [City]

• Mediation Services Near [Neighborhood/Area]

FAQ-style posts that earn trust:

• “How much does divorce mediation cost in [State/City]?”

• “What happens in the first mediation session?”

• “Can mediation work if my spouse refuses to cooperate?”

• “How long does mediation take for custody agreements?”

• “Mediation vs litigation: what’s the real difference in outcomes?”

Google’s Search Central guidance keeps returning to the same principle: content should satisfy the visitor’s need, not just exist to rank.

The Local SEO Strategy That Worked in 2023 Is Not Enough in 2026

If your entire local strategy is:

• “rank in the map pack”

• “get a few citations”

• “write a generic service page”
  …you’re exposed.

AI Overviews don’t reward generic. They reward clarity, credibility, and consistency.

And the click behavior is changing across search, not only on queries with AI Overviews. Search Engine Land highlighted broader CTR declines even beyond AIO-triggered queries, which means you should treat traffic as more fragile than before.

So what do you do?

What Mediation & Legal Businesses Must Do Now

Here’s the practical playbook.

Step 1: Make Your Brand “Easy to Recognize” Everywhere

Pick one official version of:

• business name (no variations)

• phone number (one primary)

• address formatting (standardize it)

• service area language (be consistent)

• credentials (same across bios)

Then enforce it across the web.

Step 2: Build Review Authority Like You Mean It

Set a simple internal rule:

• ask every satisfied client

• ask once, politely, at the right time

• make it easy (direct link)

• respond to reviews weekly

If you’re in mediation, you can still do this ethically while protecting privacy. Keep responses general and respectful.

Step 3: Publish Local Content That People Actually Search

Don’t write “Benefits of mediation” for the 900th time.

Write what your phone calls are already telling you:

• “Do I need a lawyer for mediation?”

• “Can we do mediation if there was infidelity?”

• “What if one party is a narcissist?” (careful tone, but yes, address the concern)

• “Is mediation confidential in [State]?” (include disclaimer and link to official resources where needed)

• “How to prepare documents for a mediation session”

You’ll be shocked how often AI summaries pull language patterns from pages that answer questions directly and calmly.

Step 4: Add Structure (Schema) Where It Helps

Schema won’t magically get you “featured,” but it removes ambiguity.

For local professional services, prioritize:

• Organization

• LocalBusiness (or the closest applicable subtype)

• Service

• FAQPage (only for real FAQs visible on-page)

• BreadcrumbList

Step 5: Track the Right Metrics (Rankings Alone Can Lie)

If AI Overviews push the pack down, you can keep your “rank” and still lose business.

Track weekly:

• Google Business Profile performance: calls, website clicks, direction requests

• Search Console: query impressions vs clicks (watch CTR shifts on high-intent queries)

• Lead tracking: form submissions, booked consults, phone call volume

If you want cleaner attribution, add UTMs to your GBP website link and use call tracking responsibly.

A 30-Day Action Plan (For a Mediation Practice)

Week 1: GBP + Consistency Cleanup

• fix categories and services

• update business description

• add new photos

• standardize NAP across top directories

Week 2: Reviews + Trust Signals

• set up review request process

• publish a “What to Expect in Your First Session” page

• update bio pages with credentials, training, associations

Week 3: Local Content Sprint

• write 3–5 real FAQs (based on client questions)

• build or improve core service pages (each with its own “Who this is for” section)

Week 4: Schema + Measurement

• add LocalBusiness + Service + FAQ schema where appropriate

• set up UTM tracking for GBP links

• create a simple dashboard of calls/clicks/directions + GSC CTR

Where Lawsuit.com Fits Into This

As AI Overviews reshape discovery, brand mentions and trusted third-party references matter more. That’s where a credible directory and content ecosystem can help.

If you’re a mediator:

• Get listed where clients already search for specialists

• Build a consistent footprint online

• Publish helpful answers that AI can summarize without misrepresenting you

That’s the direction local search is moving: less “who ranked #2,” more “who looks trustworthy across the web.”

If you want to stay visible as AI Overviews expand:

• List your mediation practice on Lawsuit.com so clients can find you beyond the map pack.

• Or request a Local Visibility Audit (GBP + reviews + citations + on-site clarity) and we’ll tell you exactly what to fix first.

Google is changing the layout. You can’t control that.
But you can control how clearly the internet describes your practice—and how easy it is for both people and AI to trust you.

Author

February 6, 2026