Help Desk / Mediation Case Watch

Mediation Case Watch

Source-linked decisions and mediator-ethics authorities, translated into practical guidance for the people who manage mediation processes.

16 published entries

Florida Supreme Court Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee (MEAC) Florida

Can a Mediator Pressure a Party to Participate or Settle?

Florida’s Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee emphasized that mediation remains voluntary and consensual as to outcome even when parties are required to participate by statute, court order, court rule, or contract. A mediator may explain applicable participation requirements and …

Decision Jan 31, 2022 Reviewed by Wayne Lazarus
Read the analysis

Florida Supreme Court Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee (MEAC) Florida

How Should Partial Settlements Be Reported in Multi-Party Cases?

Florida’s Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee concluded that a mediator handling a multi-party case may identify the parties who settled by reporting “agreement as to” those parties. The mediator should not add explanations, descriptions, recommendations, or commentary unless the …

Decision Nov 26, 2021 Reviewed by Wayne Lazarus
Read the analysis

Florida Supreme Court Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee (MEAC) Florida

When Does Helpful Information Threaten Mediator Impartiality?

Florida’s Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee concluded that a mediator may provide legal information only when qualified to do so and when the information is accurate, neutral, and consistent with party self-determination. Information should not be selectively provided in …

Decision Oct 7, 2020 Reviewed by Wayne Lazarus
Read the analysis

Florida Supreme Court Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee (MEAC) Florida

May a Mediator Decide Whether an Agreement Is Full or Partial?

Florida’s Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee concluded that a mediator may facilitate discussion about whether a settlement resolves all or only some issues, but may not make that substantive determination for the parties. A mediator may report a settlement …

Decision Jul 7, 2020 Reviewed by Wayne Lazarus
Read the analysis

Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One Arizona

Does Filing a Malpractice Claim Waive Mediation Privilege?

The Arizona Court of Appeals held that a former client did not impliedly waive Arizona’s statutory mediation-process privilege merely by filing a legal-malpractice claim arising from advice given during a mediated divorce settlement. Communications protected by A.R.S. § …

Decision Sep 22, 2015 Reviewed by Wayne Lazarus
Read the analysis

New York Court of Appeals New York

Can Both Parties Waive Mediation Confidentiality?

The New York Court of Appeals upheld disclosure of mediation-related information where the husband expressly waived confidentiality, the wife was deemed to have waived it by seeking disclosure, and the mediation agreement permitted disclosure with both parties’ consent. …

Decision Jun 26, 2008 Reviewed by Wayne Lazarus
Read the analysis