What does a mediator actually do in a complex Alabama civil case — and how is that different from a judge or an arbitrator?
A mediator is a neutral facilitator, not a decision-maker. Unlike a judge or an arbitrator, I don't rule, award, or impose anything — the parties keep full control of the outcome, and nothing is binding unless they choose to sign a settlement.
A mediator is a neutral facilitator, not a decision-maker. Unlike a judge or an arbitrator, I don't rule, award, or impose anything — the parties keep full control of the outcome, and nothing is binding unless they choose to sign a settlement. My role is to move a case that's stuck: I meet with each side confidentially, pressure-test the strengths and weaknesses both sides would rather not say out loud in open court, carry offers and reasoning back and forth, and help the parties find a number and terms everyone can live with. In a complex civil matter — insurance, personal injury, products, medical liability — that usually means helping each side see its real litigation risk clearly, so the discussion shifts from positions to what the case is actually worth settled.
Expert reviewer
William (Billy) Thomas Mills, II
J.D. | AV Preeminent | ABOTA Member | Alabama Attorney & Mediator
Reviewed October 13, 2026
View reviewer profile