Hon. Joseph J. Maltese
Hon. Joseph J. Maltese
Joseph J. Maltese, LLC
-
location_on New York, NY 10001 -
call (917) 292-9403
Hon. Joseph J. Maltese (Ret.), J.D., Ph.D.
Former New York Supreme Court Appellate & Trial Justice | Mediator, Arbitrator, Special Master & Referee
Complex Torts • Mass Torts • Products Liability • Medical Malpractice • Serious Personal Injury, Commercial & Complex Civil Disputes
New York • New Jersey • Florida | Nationwide Matters
Professional Overview
Hon. Joseph J. Maltese (Ret.) is a Mediator, Arbitrator, Special Master and Referee with decades of judicial and private practice of law experience. A former Associate Justice of the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Second Department, and the New York Supreme Courts, Judge Maltese brings extensive experience in complex civil litigation, mass torts, medical malpractice, products liability, personal injury, commercial disputes, employment discrimination and real estate matters.
During his judicial career, Judge Maltese regularly utilized mediation techniques to facilitate settlement. As a mass tort judge, he resolved thousands of pharmaceutical and other cases short of trial, providing substantial experience with complex, multi-party disputes involving scientific evidence, expert testimony, causation, liability, and damages.
He also served on the New York Litigation Coordinating Panel, including five years as its Presiding Justice, coordinating complex litigation and mass tort proceedings involving multiple parties and jurisdictions.
Before joining the judiciary, Judge Maltese spent approximately 15 years in private practice representing both plaintiffs and defendants in civil litigation and was previously a Law Clerk to a Trial Judge.
Admitted to practice law in New York, New Jersey, and Florida, Judge Maltese offers mediation and arbitration services for complex civil and commercial disputes.
________________________________________
Complex Tort & Mass Tort Mediation
Complex tort litigation has been a significant part of Judge Maltese's professional and judicial career.
His experience includes matters involving:
- Mass tort and pharmaceutical litigation
- Products liability
- Medical malpractice
- Personal injury and negligence
- Professional liability
- Premises liability
- Multi-party tort litigation
- Scientific and technical evidence
- Expert testimony and disputed causation
- Employment Discrimination Disputes
As a New York Supreme Court Justice handling mass tort litigation, Judge Maltese used mediation techniques to help resolve thousands of pharmaceutical cases without trial.
He later served as Presiding Justice of the New York Litigation Coordinating Panel, overseeing complex litigation requiring coordination among courts, attorneys, parties, and experts from multiple jurisdictions.
This experience provides Judge Maltese with a practical understanding of the evidentiary, procedural, financial, and strategic considerations that can influence settlement in sophisticated civil litigation.
Medical Malpractice, Products Liability & Scientific Evidence
Judge Maltese has experience with disputes involving medical, scientific & technical evidence. His judicial and academic work has addressed medical malpractice, pharmaceutical litigation, products liability, toxic torts, forensic science, expert testimony, and the admissibility and evaluation of scientific evidence.
In addition to his J.D., Judge Maltese holds a Ph.D., Master of Judicial Studies, and Master of Science in Forensic Examination. He has participated extensively in judicial education concerning scientific and technical evidence and has lectured and written on expert testimony, forensic science, mass tort litigation, and complex case management.
This background is particularly relevant when mediation requires parties and counsel to evaluate competing expert opinions, scientific causation, medical evidence, or technically complex liability issues.
Commercial & Complex Civil Disputes
Judge Maltese's experience extends beyond tort litigation to a broad range of commercial and civil disputes.
His background includes matters involving:
- Commercial and business litigation
- Contract disputes
- Construction disputes
- Employment matters
- Real estate litigation
- Commercial property disputes
- Cooperative and condominium matters
- Professional liability
- Multi-party civil litigation
His experience at both the trial and appellate levels provides perspective on the legal, evidentiary, procedural, and practical considerations that parties may face if a dispute continues through litigation and appeal.
Mediation Approach
Judge Maltese brings a judicial perspective to mediation informed by decades of evaluating evidence, managing complex cases, facilitating settlement, and deciding matters at both the trial and appellate levels.
His approach emphasizes careful evaluation of the factual and legal issues, realistic consideration of litigation risk, and constructive exploration of settlement opportunities.
Having worked with plaintiffs, defendants, attorneys, experts, businesses, insurers, and other stakeholders throughout his career, Judge Maltese understands that complex disputes often involve considerations extending beyond the immediate legal positions of the parties.
His role as mediator is to provide a neutral, structured environment in which parties and counsel can assess their positions, identify obstacles to settlement, and explore practical opportunities for resolution.
Arbitration
Many contracts and agreements require Arbitration rather than Mediation or a Lawsuit if a dispute arises between the parties. In Arbitration, a Neutral Arbitrator after hearing all the testimony of witnesses and reviewing the documents, photos and other evidence submitted by the parties writes a reasoned decision that is generally binding on the parties.
Judge Maltese as a seasoned Trial Judge for over 20 years and 10 years as an Appellate Justice has decided thousands of decisions at the trial and appellate level. He has extensive experience in writing reasoned decisions that serve as final judgments of disputes. Judge Maltese has the extensive experience as Neutral Arbitrator as well as a Mediator.
Judicial & Professional Background
Judge Maltese served on the New York judiciary from 1992 through 2024.
His judicial service includes:
- Associate Justice, New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Second Department — 2014–2024
- Justice, New York Supreme Court — 1996–2014
- Presiding Justice, New York Litigation Coordinating Panel — 2015–2020
- Associate Justice, New York Litigation Coordinating Panel — 2002–2015
- Judge, New York City Civil and Criminal Courts — 1992–1996
He also served as a Military Judge in the United States Army Trial Judiciary and as a JAG Officer in the Judge Advocate General’s Corps and as an Armor Officer. Judge Maltese was in the private practice of law for over 15 years after serving as Law Clerk to a Trial Judge.
Judge Maltese has served as an Adjunct Professor at New York Law School and as an Instructor with the National Judicial College. He has taught and lectured on products liability, scientific evidence, expert testimony, and managing complex civil litigation.
Education
- Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) — University of Nevada, Reno
- Master of Judicial Studies (LLM for Judges) — University of Nevada, Reno
- Master of Science, Forensic (Science) Examination — Touro College
- Master of Arts, International Relations and American Politics — New York University
- Juris Doctor (J.D.) — New York Law School
- Bachelor of Arts (B.A.) — City University of New York, John Jay College of Criminal Justice
Admissions
- New York
- New Jersey
- Florida
- US District Courts in New York, New Jersey and Florida
Write a Review
News & Blog
- Do Most Personal Injury Cases Settle in Mediation? (2026 Data)
- What Is the Average Personal Injury Settlement at Mediation? (2026 Data) | Mediate Lawsuit
- Slip and Fall Claims: Why Mediation Works
- Mediating A Car Accident Settlement: What To Know
- How to Handle Disputed Liability in Personal Injury Cases?